Browse Prior Art Database

Perspective on the Host Requirements RFCs (RFC1127)

IP.com Disclosure Number: IPCOM000001937D
Original Publication Date: 1989-Oct-01
Included in the Prior Art Database: 2000-Sep-12
Document File: 17 page(s) / 37K

Publishing Venue

Internet Society Requests For Comment (RFCs)

Related People

R.T. Braden: AUTHOR

Abstract

A working group of the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) has recently completed and published a monumental standards document on software requirements for Internet hosts [RFC-1122, RFC-1123]. This document has been published as two RFC's: "Requirements for Internet Hosts -- Communication Layers", referred to here as "HR-CL", and "Requirements for Internet Hosts -- Application and Support", referred to here as "HR-AS". Together, we refer to them as the Host Requirements RFCs, or "HR RFCs".

This text was extracted from a ASCII Text document.
This is the abbreviated version, containing approximately 8% of the total text.

Network Working Group R. Braden

Request for Comments: 1127 ISI

October 1989

A Perspective on the Host Requirements RFCs

Status of This Memo

This RFC is for information only; it does not constitute a standard,

draft standard, or proposed standard, and it does not define a

protocol. Distribution of this memo is unlimited.

Summary

This RFC contains an informal summary of the discussions and

conclusions of the IETF Working Group on Host Requirements while it

was preparing the Host Requirements RFCs. This summary has several

purposes: (1) to inform the community of host protocol issues that

need further work; (2) to preserve some history and context as a

starting point for future revision efforts; and (3) to provide some

insight into the results of the Host Requirements effort.

1. INTRODUCTION

A working group of the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) has

recently completed and published a monumental standards document on

software requirements for Internet hosts [RFC-1122, RFC-1123]. This

document has been published as two RFC's: "Requirements for Internet

Hosts -- Communication Layers", referred to here as "HR-CL", and

"Requirements for Internet Hosts -- Application and Support",

referred to here as "HR-AS". Together, we refer to them as the Host

Requirements RFCs, or "HR RFCs".

Creation of the Host Requirements document required the dedicated

efforts of about 20 Internet experts, with significant contributions

from another 20. The Host Requirements working group held 7 formal

meetings over the past 20 months, and exchanged about 3 megabytes of

electronic mail. The HR RFCs went through approximate 20 distinct

drafts.

This group of people struggled with a broad range of issues in host

implementations of the Internet protocols, attempting to reconcile

theoretical and architectural concerns with the sometimes conflicting

imperatives of the real world. The present RFC recaps the results of

this struggle, with the issues that were settled and those that

remain for future work. This exegesis has several goals:

(1) to give the Internet technical community some insight into the

results of the host requirements effort;

(2) to inform the community of areas that need further work; and

(3) to preserve some history and context of the effort as a starting

point for a future revision.

1.1 GOALS OF THE HOST REQUIREMENTS RFCs

The basic purpose of the Host Requirements RFCs is to define the

requirements for Internet host software. However, the document goes

far beyond a simple prescription of requirements, to include:

(a) a bibliography of the documents essential to an implementor;

(b) corrections and updates to the original standards RFC's;

(c) material to fill gaps in the previous specifications;

(d) limitations on...